Ford and Fisher in Carbon Freeze
One of the most powerful moments in the entire trilogy, and certainly all of Star Wars, is Han Solo’s final scene taking place in the Carbon Freeze Chamber. When re-watching the scene for this strip both Leanne and myself found ourselves tearing up. Carrie Fisher’s wavering, tearful eyes are what did it. Even without the immediate context of the preceding scenes, the moment itself remains so powerful. John Williams is at his best here, heightening everything that Ford and Fisher are portraying. It’s interesting to note all the behind the scenes drama that led to it!
The Carbon Freezing Chamber was a complicated set, built 12 feet off the stage floor. A number of problems with the heat from the arc lights and the jets of steam were compounded by rubber gaskets burning up, causing everyone to get sick and having to be evacuated. Director Irvin Kershner spent an enormous amount of time reworking the script for this tricky scene, worrying over how to make the drama and the logic work. The other problem was Carrie Fisher and Harrison Ford being on a rocky road toward their best performance in the film. At the time, Kershner admitted to Carrie it was the most difficult scene to film and he felt he was going crazy.
The “estrangement” seems to have stemmed from Carrie’s feeling she was not able to contribute as much as she liked coupled with Harrison’s dismissive attitude towards this concern. Though there quite possibly was a lot more to it. I do remember in her Bring Back Star Wars interview, an older and wiser Carrie Fisher recalled how she had a crush on Harrison Ford while working with him and joked she went on the set to have an affair. Of her two leading men, she notes there was no contest between them for her affection as it was clear who her favorite was. The dynamic between Ford and Fisher may have played into the decision to pair Han Solo and Princess Leia up as a romantic couple. The two are good friends these days, but they were close back in the day as well, at least, for a while.
“He did something funny,” Carrie bashfully, and reluctantly, admitted when interviewed by Justin Lee Collins, “I went out of the room. I came back in. He was in the closet hanging by his tie, not wearing a lot of clothes.”
Regardless of what did, or didn’t, happen, Carrie was attracted to Harrison. No surprise there. What girl wasn’t? That makes the fact their personal and professional relationships conflicted, during their most important scene, somewhat understandable.
By this time, Harrison was a huge star thanks to his charismatic scene stealing in Star Wars and iconic role as Indiana Jones in Raiders of the Lost Ark. He was now, possibly, the hottest commodity in Hollywood. Harrison Ford had serious clout. In addition to this, Kershner wanted the joint leading man’s input into Han Solo’s big scene. Justifiable. However, they did overlook Carrie in the process. It was also an important scene for Princess Leia, a stubborn and feisty character who FINALLY bares her feelings to a scoundrel that has no doubt broken many a girl’s heart. She also confirms to the viewer, unequivocally, that she loves Han Solo, not Luke. Arguably, Carrie did have a right to want to be involved in the rewrites process and discussions.
She was in her early twenties at the time of production on The Empire Strikes Back. Though Star Wars had given her cameos in various shows and productions, her youth may have been a factor in what Kershner later saw as healthy professional jealousy. Carrie had many distractions in her life from acting, but she certainly cared about protecting the integrity of Princess Leia. Billy Dee Williams remarked at the time “Carrie’s fine to work with. She’s adorable, you know; she’s not quite a disciplined performer yet, but she could be, I think, in the future.”
Carrie’s health was a problem during production, on at least two occasions she was excused early, as well as missing several days filming. Although said to be taken ill with influenza and bronchitis, years later Carrie revealed the real problem was that she had persisted in taking “hallucinogens and painkillers.” She talks about her life in candid detail in her book Wishful Drinking. The the crew “drew their own conclusions: Carrie had been up all night.” But Carrie was not the only guilty party when it came to a blip in professionalism during the BIG scene.
The book The Making of Star Wars: The Empire Strikes Back by J.W. Rinzler, includes a transcript of Kershner’s tape recording on the day of filming the Carbon Freeze scene. After spending time with Ford in the star’s trailer, Kershner had happily made rewrites and additions to the dramatic scene. Ford told Fisher that changes had been made to the script and when Kershner talked to her she was frustrated she had not been involved or present. She yelled at Harrison, causing “a couple of days of extreme tension” between them. Carrie offered an olive branch to Harrison, but he was in no mood to talk to her, further exacerbating the dysfunction between them. She warned Kershner that it could affect the kiss scene.
It must have been difficult for Carrie, concerned about the impending kiss and upset at herself as much as at Harrison for the anger between them. In the middle of blocking a scene and answering a million questions, Kershner noticed Carrie was still reeling over Harrison’s refusal to talk to her. Poor Kershner hastily consoled Carrie: “He’ll calm down, don’t worry, he’ll calm down.” Just then David Prowse walked up to him to pimp his new fitness book to the director! I laughed out loud when I first heard this, and again when I read it in the book.
Somehow Kershner kept his cool and did his best to accommodate everyone in the confusion of the steam-blasted stage. Eventually, the scene was completed. All the hair pulling and craziness on set paid off. While Star Wars had the pulse pounding trench run and Return of the Jedi had the temptation of Luke in the Emperor’s throne room, Empire has… well Empire has a lot of “best” scenes! But I think the Carbon Freeze is the most moving. We’ll be on this scene for a few strips over the next couple of weeks. I hope you will enjoy the skewering!
The transcript of Kershner and the cast and crew on the day of shooting this scene is one of the gems in the The Making of Star Wars: The Empire Strikes Back book. If you don’t already own it, then I urge you to spend the money. If not for the behind the scenes, then for the newly published photos from on and off the set.
If you’re on Twitter, chances are you are already following Carrie Fisher, but if not, check her out. Her stand up gig is awesome and her Twitter posts are typically candid and entertaining.
I realize some of the Google Ad banners may be displaying some unusual subject matter, but they are generated by Google based on the words used in the blog. The ads do not represent the views or habits of Blue Milk Special’s creators.
I’m hoping there will be an Old George fixing Harrison Ford/Han ‘ruining his dialogue’ gag in this scene. I’m actually surprised that the Definitive Director’s Cut (or whatever its called these days) didn’t dub in the ‘proper dialogue’ instead of Ford’s “I know.”
Nice Blog!
As for the strip: wonderful way for the princess to callously destroy one of the best scenes of the trilogy. I canβt wait to see how Han responds to Leia saying βI Love Youβ. π
“Well… d’uh?”
Reference the Google adds: Am I the only one who has a sudden craving for watermelon?
Excellent blog, Rod.
Reminds me of Kersh’s talk at Celebration when he revealed how the Tauntaun breath was just a bunch of blokes chain-smoking and exhaling into plastic bags. The magic of the movies.
LOL. I love how movies like these come together. A mix of cutting edge and the kitchen sink!
Btw- don’t worry about the side ads. I could look at that t-shirt ad all day π
Neil: stop endorsing your competetors! You don’t see people who sell Pepsi saying “Cool new Coke Can” do ya? π
Raiders was released after Empire. Great blog post, though π And obviously a great comic, that goes without saying.
Thanks! I should have checked the release dates. But there was no doubt at the time that Harrison Ford was the new big name in Hollywood and I’m sure it impacted the working relationship to a degree. π
No Wi-fi? How can Darth Vader be so cruel?
Perhaps she has AT&T?
Very interesting blog, thanks. Think everyone knows about the dialogue change coming up, but interesting to hear about how Carrie and Harrison got on, or not.
Thanks! Yes, most hardcore fans know about the dialogue reworking, but many of our readers were estranged from Star Wars by the prequels, or are just casual fans that don’t delve into the minutiae everyday, so I hope the article is interesting for many!
Nice blog post. I have The Making of Empire book, and I was most fascinated by this section of the book – particularly that they had Kershner miked for these discussions. In the end, I think the tension between the actors, and the obvious chemistry between Carrie and Harrison, make the carbon freeze scene so memorable – in a movie full of memorable moments.
I tell my kids all the time about how affected I was when I saw Empire in the theater as a pre-teen girl. What would happen to Han? Of course, I didn’t have the luxury, like my kids do now, to pop in the DVD of Return to see him rescued. Oh sweet torture that waiting was.
I was probably about 6 1/2 or 7 when I saw Empire, and it was on VHS. ROTJ had already come out in the theaters a year or two earlier, but I had only seen Star Wars up until then. I can’t quite remember my reaction to the film, other than knowing I was shocked by the revelation at the end, and the bit with Han. Though I don’t think I ever doubted Han Solo would be back. I think rather than being scared for Luke, I just thought it was cool to see the struggle. It seemed like a grown up movie to me, but a fun one. I think I only had to wait a week or so before we rented ROTJ and I saw how things worked out for our heroes. At the time I probably liked ROTJ more for all the silly action. *sigh*
I don’t remember which was the first I saw, SW bande don vhs from tv by my dad or the deluxe vhs of TPM i was given at some point I no longer remember, but I didn’t know about the franchise’s existence until i read the comercial for ep1 collectable plastic “bronze busts”on the backside of a kellog’s rice crisps package at my paternal grandparents old home and proceeded to ask dad what this weird/strange thing was and he set me on the course of learning about the OT. ppl might hate the PT but i wil lalways remember them fondly, because it was thanks to episode 1 i got into the cinematic wonder of sw. the only waiting time I remember would be the three years between clones and revenge. will still be precious memories for me, the tiny fragments that i remember π
i used to watch those ep1, 4, 5 and 6 over and over during my childhood so many times I can’t number them, barely ever tiring. I think, if i remember correctly that my favourite parts durign those years was the pod-race, dagobah and jabba’s palace. i even stop by youtube from time to time these days to rewatch yoda’s teachings on dagobah :3 I think my dad used to say his absolute favourite in the entire sw saga was when you see the at-at’s coming walking out of nowhere in the distance, the rebels scrambling around, halfly to defend, halfy due to being scared witless. it IS a good scene indeed.
Yeah, my memories of my first viewing are so patchy. All I remember about Star Wars (now called A New Hope) is that I was sitting on my potty with a black blanket wrapped around me when Darth Vader and the Stormtroopers stormed into the Rebel ship. It scared the crap out of me! π
What was that 4 or 5 years ago? π
Yes! You caught me out! I am only now getting used to a grown up’s toilet.
Great post! I hope Carrie likes the strip too.
i also jsut realsied that it’s words with friends that my mom’s almost addicted to playing all the time, which makes this strip’s joke seem even more… something, to me O.o
Lost for words? π
I wonder how mad that stormtrooper’s girlfriend was with him for losing her iPhone. π
Now this is interesting. They would be an awesome couple though, still today. Maybe you wanna check out this blog me and a friend has… harrisonandcarrie.blogspot.com (i guess i’m a little late with commenting on this) π
As I see it, you’re kinda overstating this scene.
The set was pretty cool… but overall the whole situation seemed more than a little silly. Why exactly did Han Solo have to be frozen in carbonite to send him to Jabba?
And even if we assume he was in some sort of stasis and didn’t need to breathe (about as far as my suspension of disbelief goes), how is it that he was quite visibly sticking out the front of a solid block of the stuff?
No really… how?
I spent ages trying to figure it out.
If he was just placed in a cuboid mold and it was filled with carbonite, he would have been fully contained within it and not visible from the outside. If it instead layered itself over his body then why would it form a smooth block behind him?
Was there some sort of gravity-warping or direction change going on out of sight whereby he wasn’t actually vertical any more, but rathering lying down and facing up, thereby causing gravity to pool it behind him while he floated mostly on the surface with only a thin layer on top as it hardened?
Anyway, I totally went off the rails there.
Han should have paid off his debt to Jabba.
He was totally irresponsible and this is simply a consequence of that irresponsibility, even though its execution was just silly.
So naturally, no sympathy from me.
Didn’t much like the Han / Leia melodrama either. Bunch of wusses.
On the upside, at least it led pretty much directly to the rescue in ROTJ… so it was kinda worth it.
Whoah… is it just me, or did the lighting effects of this scene enhance the art? I adore the minimalist style, but… damn does that look AWESOME to see such great shading and perspective, still within some of the most stylishly crisp lines out there.